DeSantis Urges Expulsion, Denaturalization, and Deportation of Congresswoman Ilhan Omar

In a dramatic escalation sparking national debate, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has publicly called for the expulsion, denaturalization, and deportation of U.S. Representative Ilhan Omar (D–MN), citing remarks she made in Somali that he claims placed Somali interests above her American allegiance.

Background

On January 27, footage surfaced of Omar appearing at a Minneapolis event speaking in Somali. Translations shared by political figures—including Somaliland's ambassador-at-large—suggested she declared herself “Somalian first, Muslim second,” promising to protect Somali interests from within the U.S. Congress.

In response, Governor DeSantis took to the social media platform X (formerly Twitter), posting: **“Expel from Congress, denaturalize and deport!”** .

DeSantis’s Stance

DeSantis and his allies argue that Omar’s comments directly conflict with her oath of office and her allegiance as a U.S. citizen. They assert such statements warrant the most severe consequences. The governor’s call follows support from other conservatives, including House GOP members, who have criticized Omar’s loyalty .

🗣️ Omar’s Defense

Omar, her team, and Somalia-origin analysts challenge the translation of her remarks. She labeled them “slanted” and “completely off,” reposting a more refined translation on X that emphasizes unity and support within Somali and Muslim communities—rather than any pledge to Somalia .

⚖️ Legal & Constitutional Barriers

The move to expel a sitting member of Congress requires a two-thirds vote in the House, an exceptionally rare and high threshold . Moreover, denaturalization is legally permissible only if citizenship was obtained through fraud—political statements do not qualify. Legal experts highlight that deportation of a naturalized citizen under these circumstances would be unprecedented and fraught with constitutional challenges .

 Broader Implications

The controversy highlights broader questions about free speech, immigration, and national identity in American politics. Supporters of DeSantis argue that figures in public office must unequivocally demonstrate loyalty. Critics warn that weaponizing translation disputes and citizenship status could chill speech and threaten democratic representation, especially for immigrants and minority lawmakers.

Governor DeSantis's call for Omar’s expulsion, denaturalization, and deportation—a dramatic and unprecedented move—faces steep procedural, legal, and constitutional barriers. Meanwhile, disputes over the translation of her Somali remarks underscore the intense partisan mix fueling the controversy.